top of page

Employed or self employed: it's not just a label!

Writer: Edward Bidgood
Edward Bidgood
Nov 9
3 min read

With more businesses using subcontractors and freelancers, the distinction between being employed and self-employed is becoming increasingly important. But did you know that simply calling someone self-employed doesn’t necessarily make them so in the eyes of HMRC?


Getting employment status wrong can have costly consequences for both businesses and workers.


What makes someone self-employed?


There is no single test to determine employment status. Instead, HMRC considers how the working relationship operates in practice, including:


  • Control: Does the business dictate when, where and how the work is carried out?

  • Substitution: Can the individual send someone else to complete the work?

  • Financial risk: Does the worker provide their own equipment, correct mistakes at their own expense or risk making a loss?

  • Mutual obligations: Is the business obliged to offer work, and is the individual obliged to accept it?

  • Independence: Does the individual work for other customers and operate a genuine business of their own?


No single factor determines the outcome. It is the overall working arrangement that matters.


For employers: getting it wrong can be expensive


Engaging someone on a self-employed basis can appear attractive, with less payroll administration and no employer’s National Insurance contributions.


However, if HMRC decides that the individual should have been treated as an employee for tax purposes, the business could face a substantial bill for unpaid PAYE and National Insurance, together with interest and potentially penalties.


There are also employment law considerations. Individuals may be entitled to holiday pay, minimum wage and other statutory protections, such as maternity pay depending on their employment status.


For workers: consider the bigger picture


Self-employment offers flexibility, independence and the opportunity to claim allowable business expenses against taxable profits.


However, it also brings responsibilities. Self-employed individuals generally need to manage their own tax affairs, keep appropriate records and make provision for tax and National Insurance.


They will not normally receive the same benefits as employees, such as paid annual leave, statutory sick pay or employer pension contributions.


It is therefore important to consider the overall financial position rather than simply comparing hourly or daily rates.



Common in agriculture and rural businesses


Employment status can be particularly relevant in farming, where casual labour, relief milkers, agricultural contractors and seasonal workers are commonplace.

For example, a relief milker who works regularly on one farm, follows set hours and uses the farmer’s equipment may have a different employment status from an independent contractor who provides services to several farms, uses their own machinery and decides how the work is completed.


Each arrangement needs to be considered on its own merits.


Common misconceptions


“I work for several businesses, so I must be self-employed.”


Not necessarily! Employment status depends on the nature of each working relationship, rather than simply the number of customers you have. You could work for several businesses and still be classed as an employee of each.


“I have a UTR, submit invoices and complete my own tax return, so I must be self-employed.”


Wrong! Having a Unique Taxpayer Reference (UTR), issuing invoices or completing a Self-Assessment tax return does not automatically make you self-employed. HMRC looks beyond the paperwork to establish how the working relationship operates in practice. It’s what you actually do that counts, not how you describe it!


Don’t leave it to chance


HMRC provides a Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool to help businesses and individuals assess their position. However, it is important that the answers accurately reflect the working arrangements.


The key message


Employment status is determined by the reality of the working relationship, not simply what is written on an invoice or agreed between the parties.


If you are unsure whether someone should be treated as employed or self-employed, seeking advice now could prevent an expensive problem later.

 
 
 

Comments


|

Copyright © 2024 James Biggs, Partner at Mitchells.

Registered to carry on audit work in the UK; regulated for a range of investment business activities; and authorised to carry out the reserved legal activity of non-contentious probate in England and Wales by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales

bottom of page