top of page

Farm profits, look beyond the tax bill

Writer: Michelle Batting
Michelle Batting
Nov 2
4 min read

Your accounts can and should tell you far more than how much

tax you have to pay.



For many farming businesses, the annual accounts meeting can naturally become focused on one question: “How much tax have I got to pay?”


It is an important question, but your accounts contain a wealth of information that can help you understand how your farm is actually performing and where improvements could be made.


With margins under pressure and input costs continuing to fluctuate, understanding the figures behind your farming business has never been more valuable.


Start with the gross margin


A good starting point is your gross profit margin – effectively, what is left from your sales after taking account of the direct costs of producing them.


If turnover has increased, it is easy to assume the farm has had a better year. But if feed, fertiliser, fuel or other direct costs have risen at a faster rate, the additional turnover may not have translated into additional profit.


Where the farm has several enterprises, looking at them separately can be particularly useful to see which areas of the business are performing best.


Keep an eye on machinery costs


Machinery can be one of the largest costs within a farming business, but the true cost isn’t always immediately obvious. Repairs, fuel, insurance, hire purchase interest, depreciation and regular replacement of machinery can add up to a significant annual figure.


A large repair bill on an ageing tractor might prompt the question of whether replacement is becoming more economical. Equally, buying a new machine purely to reduce a tax bill rarely makes financial sense.


Your accounts can help identify how much machinery is really costing the business and whether those costs are increasing over time.


Don’t forget the cost of borrowing


Finance costs can easily become lost amongst the other figures, there may be several loans, hire purchase agreements or overdraft facilities.


When considering a new investment, therefore, the question shouldn’t simply be “can we borrow the money?” but also “can the business comfortably afford the borrowing?”


Profit doesn’t necessarily mean cash in the bank


One of the most important distinctions in any business is the difference between profit and cash.


A farm may report a healthy profit but still experience pressure on the bank account. Capital repayments on loans, machinery purchases, increasing stock levels, tax payments and drawings can all consume cash without necessarily appearing as expenses in the profit and loss account.


Working capital is therefore an important part of the picture. If debtors are increasing, creditors are being paid more quickly or more money is tied up in livestock and crops, the business may need considerably more cash simply to operate.


How much is being taken out of the business?


Drawings are another figure worth reviewing regularly. There is nothing wrong with taking money from the farm, ultimately, the business needs to provide an income for the people running it. However, drawings need to be sustainable.


If a farm generates £60,000 of cash but £80,000 is being withdrawn privately each year, the difference has to come from somewhere, perhaps increasing the overdraft or delaying investment.


Reviewing drawings alongside profitability can highlight whether the business is genuinely supporting the family’s requirements.



Compare more than one year


Looking at one set of accounts in isolation only tells part of the story. Comparing two, three, or four years can reveal trends which may otherwise be missed.


Turnover might be increasing steadily, for example, while the net profit margin is gradually falling. Machinery repairs may have crept upwards each year, or borrowing costs may now represent a much larger proportion of profit.


These trends can help identify areas requiring attention before they become a bigger problem.


Turn the accounts into a planning tool


Historical accounts tell you what has already happened, but their real value comes from using that information to help make future decisions. It’s always better to be proactive, rather than reactive. Once you understand the farm’s current performance, you can start asking “What if?”


What happens if milk or livestock prices fall by 10%? Can the business afford another employee? What would the repayments on a new tractor look like? Could the farm support additional borrowing to purchase land? How much cash needs to be retained for the next tax payment?

Budgets and cash flow forecasts don’t need to predict the future perfectly to be useful. They provide a framework for making decisions and allow different scenarios to be considered before committing to them.


Look beyond the bottom line


Your annual accounts shouldn’t simply be viewed as something required by HMRC. Used properly, they can help you understand which parts of the farm are making money, where costs are increasing, how much cash the business is generating and whether future investment is affordable.


So, at your next accounts meeting, don’t just ask “How much tax do I have to pay?” Ask “What are these figures telling me about my business?”

 
 
 

Comments


|

Copyright © 2024 James Biggs, Partner at Mitchells.

Registered to carry on audit work in the UK; regulated for a range of investment business activities; and authorised to carry out the reserved legal activity of non-contentious probate in England and Wales by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales

bottom of page