When farm grants exceed farming income

Is your VAT recovery still safe?

As environmental scheme payments become an increasingly important source of farm income, their impact on VAT recovery deserves closer attention. For farming businesses that also have let residential cottages, there may be further VAT complications to consider.
When grant income exceeds farming turnover
Payments through the Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI), Countryside Stewardship and other environmental schemes now represent a significant proportion of income for many farms, sometimes exceeding traditional agricultural sales. While these payments provide valuable financial support, could they affect the amount of VAT a farming business can recover?
The answer depends not simply on the level of grant income, but on the nature of the farm’s activities and how its expenditure relates to the business.
Are environmental payments subject to VAT?
Many agricultural grants fall outside the scope of VAT because they are not payments for a supply of goods or services. However, the treatment depends on the terms of each scheme and what the farmer is required to provide in return. Crucially, receiving income outside the scope of VAT does not automatically restrict input VAT recovery. The key distinction is whether expenditure relates to business or non-business activities.
Does substantial grant income restrict VAT recovery?
Consider a farm receiving agricultural sales of £100,000 and SFI and Countryside Stewardship payments £150,000, resulting in total income of £250,000. Although grants represent 60% of total income, this does not mean the farm must restrict its VAT recovery by 60%.
HMRC’s guidance confirms that outside-the-scope income does not, in itself, make an activity non-business or require input VAT to be apportioned. For example, expenditure on soil improvement, field margins or land management may remain part of the wider farming business, even when supported by environmental payments. However, where land is removed from commercial agricultural production and used for genuinely non-business activities, VAT recovery on related expenditure may need to be restricted. The determining factors are how the land is used, the activities undertaken and their relationship to the taxable farming business.
Why reviewing VAT recovery matters
As farms reduce livestock numbers, take land out of production or increasingly focus on environmental management, their VAT recovery position may change. Expenditure on fencing, machinery, habitat creation, land improvements and general overheads should be reviewed to establish whether it relates to taxable business activities. Where costs support both business and non-business activities, a fair and reasonable apportionment may be necessary.
The important point is that VAT recovery is not restricted automatically in proportion to grant income. It is changes in the underlying activities, rather than the level of grant receipts alone, that may affect entitlement.
Farm cottages, an additional VAT complication
Many farms also receive income from residential cottages. Ordinary residential lettings are generally exempt from VAT, potentially bringing the business within the partial exemption rules. VAT directly attributable to taxable farming activities is normally recoverable, whereas VAT relating to exempt residential lettings is generally irrecoverable unless the de minimis rules apply. For example, VAT on repairs to a cottage let under a long-term residential tenancy will generally relate to exempt income. Shared costs, including accountancy fees and other overheads, may also require apportionment. This becomes particularly important when undertaking substantial property renovations or improvements.
Could the partial exemption de minimis rules help?
Farms with relatively small amounts of exempt input VAT may still qualify for full recovery under the partial exemption de minimis rules.
Under the principal test, exempt input VAT must be:
No more than £625 per month on average; and
No more than 50% of total input VAT.
Alternative statutory tests may also be available.
A major cottage refurbishment could cause these limits to be exceeded, potentially restricting VAT recovery. The implications should therefore be considered before committing to significant expenditure. It is also important to distinguish ordinary residential lettings, which are generally VAT-exempt, from furnished holiday accommodation, which is generally a taxable supply for VAT purposes.
Two separate VAT issues
Farms receiving environmental grants alongside residential rental income may need to consider two distinct sets of rules:
Business and non-business apportionment: Relevant where expenditure supports activities that fall outside the farm’s economic business.
Partial exemption: Applies where the farm makes both taxable supplies, such as agricultural sales, and exempt supplies, such as residential rents.
Both may apply to the same farming business. Where necessary, non-business VAT must be identified before calculating partial exemption.
What should farmers do?
Farming businesses should review their VAT arrangements where environmental payments have become a major source of income, particularly if traditional agricultural operations have reduced significantly.
They should also assess the VAT treatment of expenditure; maintain clear records linking costs to activities and consider partial exemption before undertaking major works on residential rental properties.
Don’t take VAT recovery for granted
High levels of environmental grant income do not automatically reduce VAT recovery. However, changes in farming activities can affect entitlement, while residential cottage lettings introduce separate partial exemption considerations.
For farms where grants now exceed agricultural turnover, a timely VAT review could help identify potential restrictions, avoid unexpected costs and protect valuable VAT recovery entitlements.



Comments